Why Did Anaheim Trade Frederik Andersen? The Trade That Shook Anaheim

James Felix

Updated on:

anaheim trade frederik andersen

In the world of professional sports, player trades are common occurrences. They can be driven by various factors, including the need to improve a team’s performance, salary cap considerations, or the desire to acquire young and promising talent.

One such trade that garnered significant attention and speculation was the Anaheim Ducks’ decision to trade their star goaltender, Frederik Andersen, to the Toronto Maple Leafs in June 2016.

The trade sent shockwaves through the NHL community and left many fans and experts wondering why the Ducks would part ways with a goaltender who had been a key contributor to their success.

Why Did Anaheim Trade Frederik Andersen?

Anaheim traded Frederik Andersen, their former goaltender, for several reasons. The decision was influenced by a combination of factors, including salary cap considerations, the emergence of other promising goaltenders in the organization, and the desire to address other team needs.

Anaheim traded Frederik Andersen, the former goaltender for the Ducks, for several reasons:

Salary Cap Constraints

NHL teams operate under a salary cap, which limits the amount of money they can spend on player salaries. After the 2015-2016 season, Andersen was due for a significant contract extension, and the Ducks were faced with the challenge of managing their cap space.

Trading Andersen allowed them to allocate resources more efficiently.

Emerging Talent in the Organization

At the time of the trade, the Anaheim Ducks had promising young goaltenders in their system, notably John Gibson.

Gibson had already shown great potential and was considered the future of the franchise in goal. This gave the Ducks confidence that they had a capable successor to Andersen.

Depth at Other Positions

The Ducks might have had needs in other areas of their roster that they believed could be addressed through a trade involving Andersen.

This could include acquiring players at different positions or stockpiling draft picks for future talent development.

Trade Market Dynamics

The trade market in the NHL is constantly evolving, and teams assess potential deals based on a variety of factors, including the demand for certain players and the availability of other assets.

When there was significant interest in Andersen from other teams, it would have influenced Anaheim’s decision.

Long-Term Planning

NHL teams often engage in long-term strategic planning. This can involve making decisions that set the team up for success not just in the immediate future, but also in the years to come.

Trading Andersen may have been part of the Ducks’ broader vision for their roster.

Potential Locker Room Dynamics

Sometimes, factors beyond performance on the ice can influence a trade.

If there were any concerns about team chemistry or locker room dynamics involving Andersen, it could have played a role in the decision to trade him.

Contract Negotiation Disagreements

Negotiations between a player and a team regarding a new contract can sometimes become contentious.

When there were disagreements or difficulties in coming to terms on a new contract, this could have been a contributing factor.

Frederik Andersen’s Journey to the NHL

Frederik Andersen's Journey to the NHL

Frederik Andersen’s journey to the NHL is a remarkable story of determination and talent. Born in Herning, Denmark, on October 2, 1989, Andersen’s path to professional hockey was quite unconventional, given that Denmark is not traditionally known as a hockey powerhouse.

However, his talent and work ethic paved the way for him to break into the highest level of the sport.

Early Years in Denmark

Andersen’s journey began in his native Denmark, where he initially developed his passion for hockey.

Although not a traditional hockey hotbed, Denmark has a growing hockey community, and Andersen quickly stood out as a young goaltender.

Transition to Sweden

Recognizing the need for more advanced competition and development, Andersen made a significant move to further his career.

He moved to Sweden to play for Frolunda HC in the Swedish Hockey League (SHL), one of Europe’s top professional leagues. This transition was a crucial step in his development, exposing him to higher-level competition.

Drafted by the Anaheim Ducks

Andersen’s impressive performances in the SHL caught the attention of NHL scouts, and in 2012, he was selected by the Anaheim Ducks in the third round (87th overall) of the NHL Entry Draft. This marked the beginning of his journey to the NHL.

AHL and NHL Debut

After being drafted by the Ducks, Andersen made his way to North America to join the Ducks’ AHL affiliate, the Norfolk Admirals.

His success in the AHL quickly led to his NHL debut. On October 20, 2013, Andersen made his first NHL start against the Dallas Stars, and he showcased his skills and poise in the crease.

Developing into an NHL Goaltender

Andersen’s time with the Ducks was marked by impressive performances that solidified his position in the NHL.

His standout attributes included his size, athleticism, and ability to remain calm under pressure. He earned a reputation as a reliable presence in the Anaheim crease.

Shared Duties with John Gibson

One unique aspect of Andersen’s NHL journey with the Ducks was the sharing of goaltending duties with another promising young netminder, John Gibson.

This duo formed one of the most potent goaltending tandems in the league, with both goalies pushing each other to excel.

Playoff Success and Regular Season Performances

Andersen played a pivotal role in the Ducks’ success, helping the team reach the playoffs consistently.

He also had strong regular-season performances, further establishing himself as a key contributor to Anaheim’s success.

Trade to the Toronto Maple Leafs

In June 2016, the Anaheim Ducks made the decision to trade Frederik Andersen to the Toronto Maple Leafs.

The trade sent him to Toronto in exchange for draft picks, marking a significant turning point in his career and the beginning of a new chapter as the Maple Leafs’ starting goaltender.

Frederik Andersen’s Arrival in Anaheim

Frederik Andersen's Arrival in Anaheim

Frederik Andersen’s arrival in Anaheim marked the beginning of his NHL career and introduced him to a new level of competition in North America.

After being drafted by the Anaheim Ducks in 2012, Andersen transitioned from playing in the Swedish Hockey League (SHL) to the American Hockey League (AHL) before making his debut in the NHL.

Transition to North America

After being drafted by the Anaheim Ducks, Andersen left his native Denmark and made a significant transition to North America.

This move was a pivotal step in his career, as he prepared to compete at the highest level of professional hockey.

Joining the Norfolk Admirals (AHL)

Upon arriving in North America, Andersen was assigned to the Norfolk Admirals, the Ducks’ AHL affiliate. The AHL serves as a developmental league for young prospects on their path to the NHL.

Andersen’s time with the Admirals provided him with valuable experience and exposure to the North American style of play.

Impressive AHL Performance

Andersen’s time in the AHL was marked by outstanding performances. He quickly established himself as a standout goaltender in the league, showcasing his skills and potential to become an NHL-caliber netminder.

Call-up to the NHL

Andersen’s strong play in the AHL did not go unnoticed by the Ducks’ coaching staff and management. Recognizing his talent and potential, Andersen received his first call-up to the NHL.

This marked a significant milestone in his journey to the highest level of professional hockey.

NHL Debut

On October 20, 2013, Frederik Andersen made his NHL debut for the Anaheim Ducks. He started in goal against the Dallas Stars, and his poised performance in the crease demonstrated his readiness to compete at the highest level.

Andersen’s debut was a momentous occasion in his career, signaling the beginning of his NHL tenure.

Establishing Himself in the Ducks’ Lineup

Following his NHL debut, Andersen continued to impress with his consistent and reliable play.

His size, agility, and ability to remain composed under pressure earned him the trust of the coaching staff and his teammates. Andersen quickly became a key contributor to the Ducks’ success.

Goaltending Tandem with John Gibson

One of the intriguing dynamics of Andersen’s time in Anaheim was his partnership with fellow goaltender John Gibson. The Ducks boasted an exceptional goaltending tandem, with both Andersen and Gibson pushing each other to excel.

This healthy competition in the crease elevated the team’s overall goaltending performance.

Andersen’s Contract Status and Negotiations

Frederik Andersen’s contract status and negotiations played a crucial role in the decision-making process that ultimately led to his trade from the Anaheim Ducks to the Toronto Maple Leafs. As he approached the end of his entry-level contract, Andersen’s performance and potential market value became significant factors in the Ducks’ roster decisions.

Entry-Level Contract

Upon being drafted by the Anaheim Ducks in 2012, Frederik Andersen signed his entry-level contract. Entry-level contracts are typically three-year agreements for players entering the NHL.

During this period, players are subject to certain salary and performance-related restrictions.

Impressive Performances

Throughout his tenure with the Ducks, Andersen’s consistent and stellar performances elevated his status in the league.

His reliability in the crease and ability to deliver under pressure garnered attention from fans, analysts, and, most importantly, NHL front offices.

Approaching Restricted Free Agency (RFA) Status

At the conclusion of his entry-level contract, Andersen was on the verge of becoming a restricted free agent (RFA). This meant that while he was not entirely free to sign with any team, his negotiating power was significantly increased.

RFAs are players whose contracts have expired, but their current team has the right to match any offers made by other NHL clubs.

Rising Market Value

Andersen’s impressive play during his entry-level contract contributed to an increase in his market value.

As one of the league’s promising young goaltenders, Andersen was poised to command a more substantial contract in his next negotiation.

Salary Cap Considerations

The NHL operates under a salary cap system, which places a limit on the total amount of money a team can spend on player salaries in a given season. For the Anaheim Ducks, managing their salary cap effectively was a critical factor in roster decisions.

Balancing the financial resources allocated to goaltending, among other positions, was essential in building a competitive team.

Negotiation Dilemma

As Andersen approached restricted free agency, the Ducks faced a significant decision. They had to weigh the potential cost of signing Andersen to a new contract against the long-term financial implications.

This decision was complicated by the presence of another highly talented goaltender in John Gibson, who was also due for a new contract.

Trade as a Solution

Given the situation, the Ducks were presented with two primary options: sign Andersen to a new contract, potentially committing a significant portion of their salary cap to their goaltending tandem, or explore trade opportunities.

Trading Andersen allowed the Ducks to receive assets in return while also addressing their goaltending depth and salary cap concerns.

Anaheim’s Financial Considerations and Cap Constraints

The trade of Frederik Andersen from the Anaheim Ducks to the Toronto Maple Leafs was influenced significantly by Anaheim’s financial considerations and salary cap constraints.

Managing the salary cap is a crucial aspect of building a competitive NHL team, and the Ducks had to carefully navigate their financial resources to make decisions that would benefit the overall roster.

NHL Salary Cap System

The NHL operates under a salary cap system, which sets a limit on the total amount of money a team can spend on player salaries in a given season. This system is designed to promote competitive balance among teams.

Cap Space Allocation

Each team must allocate its available cap space to players across various positions, including forwards, defensemen, and goaltenders. Balancing these allocations is essential in building a competitive and well-rounded roster.

Goaltending Tandem

The Anaheim Ducks were in the unique position of having two highly capable goaltenders Frederik Andersen and John Gibson.

Both Andersen and Gibson demonstrated the potential to be starting goaltenders in the NHL, which presented a challenge for the Ducks’ management in terms of salary cap allocation.

Contract Negotiations

Frederik Andersen’s contract negotiation was a critical factor in Anaheim’s decision-making process. 

As he approached restricted free agency, his impressive performance and potential market value meant that he would likely command a significant salary increase.

Commitment to John Gibson

The Ducks’ management had to make a decision between Frederik Andersen and John Gibson, both of whom were approaching the end of their entry-level contracts.

Committing to one goaltender for the long term was necessary to effectively manage their salary cap.

Long-Term Planning

Making decisions about the goaltending position was not just about the current season but also about long-term planning.

The Ducks needed to consider how their cap space would be allocated in the coming years, factoring in potential raises for other players and future signings.

Asset Management

In addition to goaltending considerations, the Ducks also needed to ensure they had the financial flexibility to address other areas of their roster, such as defense and forward positions.

This required strategic asset management to balance cap space allocations across the team.

Acquisition of Draft Picks

The trade of Frederik Andersen to the Toronto Maple Leafs provided the Ducks with valuable assets in return, including a first-round draft pick in 2016 (used to select Sam Steel) and a second-round draft pick in 2017 (used to select Maxime Comtois).

These assets were instrumental in replenishing Anaheim’s prospect pool and planning for the future.

The Impact of the Trade

The trade of Frederik Andersen to the Toronto Maple Leafs had several significant impacts on both teams involved, as well as on the goaltender’s career.

For the Anaheim Ducks:

Salary Cap Flexibility

By trading Andersen, the Ducks gained valuable salary cap flexibility.

This allowed them to allocate resources to other areas of their roster, such as signing key players and addressing their needs in defense and forward positions.

Organizational Depth

The assets acquired in the trade, including Sam Steel and Maxime Comtois, bolstered the Ducks’ prospect pool and provided a pathway for young talent to develop within the organization.

Commitment to John Gibson

The trade solidified the Ducks’ commitment to John Gibson as their starting goaltender.

Gibson has since become one of the league’s premier netminders, and the decision to trade Andersen has been vindicated by his exceptional performances.

For the Toronto Maple Leafs:

Goaltending Stability

The acquisition of Frederik Andersen provided the Maple Leafs with a reliable and consistent presence in the crease.

Andersen’s strong play has been instrumental in the team’s progression and competitiveness.

Leadership and Experience

Andersen brought a wealth of experience and leadership to a young Maple Leafs roster.

His calm demeanor and ability to handle pressure situations have been invaluable to the team’s development.

For Frederik Andersen

The trade to Toronto marked a significant turning point in Andersen’s career. It provided him with an opportunity to become a true number-one goaltender in the NHL and showcase his talents on a larger stage.

Andersen’s success with the Maple Leafs has solidified his status as one of the league’s top goaltenders.


Why did the Anaheim Ducks trade Frederik Andersen?

The Ducks traded Frederik Andersen to address their goaltending depth and contract negotiation concerns while acquiring valuable assets in return.

What was the main reason for trading Andersen?

The primary reason for trading Andersen was to make a long-term commitment to John Gibson as their starting goaltender, managing their salary cap more effectively.

What assets did the Ducks receive in the trade?

In exchange for Andersen, the Ducks received a 2016 first-round draft pick (used to select Sam Steel) and a 2017 second-round draft pick.

How did the trade impact the Toronto Maple Leafs?

The trade provided the Maple Leafs with a stable and reliable starting goaltender in Andersen, addressing a longstanding issue in their roster.

How has Frederik Andersen’s career fared since the trade?

Since the trade, Andersen has established himself as one of the league’s top goaltenders with the Maple Leafs, solidifying his status as a premier netminder in the NHL.

To Recap

The trade of Frederik Andersen from the Anaheim Ducks to the Toronto Maple Leafs was a pivotal moment in the careers of all parties involved.

While initially met with surprise and speculation, the trade was driven by a combination of factors, including goaltending depth, contract negotiations, asset acquisition, and Toronto’s goaltending needs.

The trade ultimately benefited both the Ducks and the Maple Leafs, as well as Frederik Andersen himself, as he has flourished in his role as Toronto’s star goaltender.

In the ever-evolving landscape of professional sports, this trade serves as a reminder of the complex decisions and considerations that teams must weigh in their pursuit of success.

Photo of author

James Felix

As Head Boy's Ice Hockey Coach at Milton Academy, I foster teamwork, discipline, and skill development. Our success relies on dedication and refining tactics. We balance academics with on-ice performance, shaping well-rounded individuals. Together, we uphold Milton Academy's tradition of excellence in athletics and academics. LinkedIn

Leave a Comment